Atlas vs Mayflower (2026): Cost, Coverage and Complaint Records
Atlas Van Lines and Mayflower Transit are both national van lines whose networks are owned by their agents: Atlas calls itself "The Agents' Van Line", and Mayflower's parent UniGroup says it is owned by its van lines' agents. On price, only Mayflower publishes a figure (about $8,000 to over $10,000 for a 2-3 bedroom long-distance move); Atlas publishes cost factors but no dollar range. Where they differ in writing is valuation: Mayflower publishes its Full Value Protection terms, Atlas does not.
More van-line comparisons: North American vs Allied, Allied vs United and Allied vs Mayflower.
Sources: Atlas Van Lines: how to compare residential moving costs in 2026 (page dated 30 July 2026; checked 13 October 2026); Mayflower estimate the cost of a long-distance move page (checked 2 November 2026); Atlas Van Lines: history (checked 14 October 2026); Atlas Van Lines: about Atlas (checked 14 October 2026); Mayflower: about us (checked 14 October 2026); UniGroup home page (checked 14 October 2026). Each carrier's own published figure for a 2-3 bedroom home, in its own words. Neither publishes a price for one specific 1,500-mile job.
Side-by-Side: What Each Carrier States
| Item | Atlas Van Lines | Mayflower Transit |
|---|---|---|
| Founded | 1948, by 33 moving and storage firms | 1927, Indianapolis |
| Parent company | Atlas World Group, Inc. | UniGroup (since 1995) |
| Who owns the parent | Agent-owned ("The Agents' Van Line"); returned to agent ownership in 1988 | UniGroup is owned by its van lines' agents; a cooperative since 2018 |
| Agent network, as stated | More than 200 agents; nearly 350 local Atlas movers | 200 affiliated agencies |
| Storage in transit | Short- or long-term storage in transit; no time limit stated | Storage offered; no time limit stated |
| Valuation in the quote | Valuation options offered; terms not published | Full Value Protection in every initial quote, at $6 x estimated weight |
| Price promise on its site | Not stated on the pages we read | Binding quote, e-accepted |
| USDOT / MC | 125550 / MC-79658 | 125563 / MC-2934 |
Sources: Atlas Van Lines: history (checked 14 October 2026); Mayflower: about us (checked 14 October 2026); Atlas Van Lines: about Atlas (checked 14 October 2026); UniGroup home page (checked 14 October 2026); Atlas Van Lines long-distance moving services page (checked 14 October 2026); Mayflower storage page (checked 14 October 2026); Mayflower moving protection page (checked 14 October 2026); Mayflower home page (checked 14 October 2026); FMCSA SAFER company snapshot (checked 14 October 2026). Each cell is what that carrier, its parent or FMCSA states. Where a carrier's site does not say, the cell says so; we do not fill it from another carrier.
How Each Network Is Owned
Atlas began in 1948, when 33 moving and storage firms incorporated as Atlas Van-Lines to run their own coast-to-coast cooperative. Its history records a return to agent ownership in 1988, and today more than 200 Atlas agents own and operate the equipment and warehouses that carry Atlas moves; the parent is Atlas World Group, Inc.
Mayflower was founded in Indianapolis in 1927 and became part of UniGroup in 1995. UniGroup, which also owns United Van Lines, says it is owned by its van lines' agents, and its shareholders voted to become a cooperative in 2018. Mayflower works through 200 affiliated agencies.
So both are agent-owned. Neither carrier publishes evidence that its ownership changes handling, claims or price, and this page does not claim that it does. What you can compare is in writing: the estimate, its valuation terms, its storage period, and FMCSA's complaint counts.
Sources: Atlas Van Lines: history (checked 14 October 2026); Atlas Van Lines: about Atlas (checked 14 October 2026); Mayflower: about us (checked 14 October 2026); UniGroup home page (checked 14 October 2026); United Van Lines: about us (checked 14 October 2026).
FMCSA Complaint Counts
| Carrier (USDOT) | 2023 | 2024 | 2025 | 2026 to date | Trucks + tractors |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Atlas (125550) | 9 | 9 | 8 | 6 | 2,731 |
| Mayflower (125563) | 9 | 6 | 13 | 26 | 769 |
Complaints lodged in FMCSA's National Consumer Complaint Database against each carrier's own USDOT number; FMCSA's data is from 25 September 2026, so 2026 covers part of the year. FMCSA warns that larger companies handle more moves and so are more likely to draw complaints, and points to fleet size as a guide to scale. It does not publish how many moves each carrier handled, so these counts cannot be turned into a complaint rate, and we do not rank carriers by them. The trucks and tractors are those registered to the van line's own USDOT number.
Sources: FMCSA Search Movers & Complaint History (page dated 25 September 2026; checked 14 October 2026).
How to Compare Them
- Get a written estimate from both, for the same inventory, dates and services. With no Atlas price published, the estimate is the only comparison.
- Ask Atlas for its valuation terms in writing. Mayflower builds Full Value Protection into its first quote at $6 a pound times the estimated weight; ask Atlas which option its estimate assumes, the amount and the cost. See moving insurance.
- Get the storage period in writing. Neither states a limit for storage in transit.
- For specialty items, ask each how a piano, artwork or antiques will be packed and which valuation applies to them.
- Widen the field. United publishes the same 2-3 bedroom range as Mayflower (over $8,000 to over $10,000); Allied and North American publish $6,700-$9,250 for a 2-3 bedroom move over 400 miles. See North American vs Allied.
What You Will Actually Be Quoted
The figures above are what companies publish. A mover's written estimate for your move is governed by federal rules (49 CFR Part 375), and these are the parts that change what you pay.
Binding vs non-binding estimates, in full · Cost calculator with these lines
Sources: 49 CFR Part 375, Appendix A: Your Rights and Responsibilities When You Move (Cornell LII) (checked 14 October 2026); eCFR: 49 CFR Part 375 (page dated 9 October 2026; checked 13 October 2026); U-Pack: how much does PODS cost compared to U-Pack (page dated 18 March 2026; checked 14 October 2026); U-Pack: how much does it cost to move across the country (page dated 22 June 2026; checked 13 November 2026).
FAQ
Is Atlas or Mayflower cheaper?
There is no published basis to say. Mayflower puts a 2-3 bedroom long-distance move at about $8,000 to over $10,000. Atlas's own 2026 cost guide lists the factors that set a price but no dollar range, so there is nothing to set against Mayflower's figure. Get a written estimate from each for the same inventory, dates and valuation.
How are Atlas and Mayflower owned?
Both are agent-owned networks. Atlas calls itself "The Agents' Van Line": it was formed in 1948 by 33 moving and storage firms as their own cooperative and returned to agent ownership in 1988; its parent is Atlas World Group, Inc. Mayflower, founded in 1927, joined UniGroup in 1995; UniGroup, which also owns United Van Lines, says it is owned by its van lines' agents and became a cooperative in 2018.
How many FMCSA complaints do Atlas and Mayflower have?
FMCSA's complaint history (data from 25 September 2026) shows 8 complaints against Atlas's USDOT number in 2025 and 6 so far in 2026, against 13 and 26 for Mayflower. Atlas registers more trucks and tractors to its own USDOT number (2,731 against 769). FMCSA warns that larger companies draw more complaints and does not publish move counts, so these are counts, not rates.
Do both handle pianos, art and antiques?
Both say so: Atlas lists specialty item handling among its long-distance services, and Mayflower offers specialty moving for pianos, artwork and antiques. Neither publishes a price or a claims record for those items, so ask each estimate how they will be packed and which valuation applies.
Which has clearer valuation terms?
Mayflower publishes its terms: Full Value Protection is included in every initial quote, at the estimated weight times $6 a pound (6,800 lbs gives $40,800). Atlas says it offers valuation coverage options but does not publish them. Under federal rules every interstate estimate must set out Full Value Protection, which applies unless you waive it in writing, and Released Value at no more than 60 cents a pound per article.
Does either move internationally?
Yes. Mayflower offers international moves, and Atlas World Group International provides international transportation for Atlas agents and their customers. International moves are quoted separately from domestic ones.
Sources: Mayflower estimate the cost of a long-distance move page (checked 2 November 2026); Atlas Van Lines: how to compare residential moving costs in 2026 (page dated 30 July 2026; checked 13 October 2026); Atlas Van Lines: history (checked 14 October 2026); Atlas Van Lines: about Atlas (checked 14 October 2026); Mayflower: about us (checked 14 October 2026); UniGroup home page (checked 14 October 2026); FMCSA Search Movers & Complaint History (page dated 25 September 2026; checked 14 October 2026); Atlas Van Lines long-distance moving services page (checked 14 October 2026); Mayflower storage page (checked 14 October 2026); Mayflower moving protection page (checked 14 October 2026); Mayflower home page (checked 14 October 2026); eCFR: 49 CFR Part 375 (page dated 9 October 2026; checked 13 October 2026).